Challenger David Lansford beat Mayor Gayle Blumfield with 63-percent of the vote.
When early voting came in, Lansford had 61-percent of the vote and a lead that he didn't give up.
In District 1, Janice Elliott went up against Randall Crowder. Crowder won with 66-percent of the vote.
In District 2, Sandra Taylor-Sawyer beat John Jones with 56-percent of the vote.
In District 3, Robert Sandoval ran unopposed.
In District 4, R.L. "Rube" Render lost to Chris Bryant. Bryant received 57-percent of the vote.
In the only question on the ballot, the voters overwhelmingly voted for the restriction of dual commissioners.